Difference between revisions of "Talk:Torkel Failed Apprentice"
(Created) |
(More talk with Andrew. The 5 XP discrepancy decided in Torkel's favor.) |
||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
I finally got around to entering Torkel into Metacreator and I found a couple of issues. | I finally got around to entering Torkel into Metacreator and I found a couple of issues. | ||
| − | First, I had retroactively changed some of Torkel's activities so he only has 2 seasons of Exposure to Teaching, not 3. | + | First, I had retroactively changed some of Torkel's activities so he only has 2 seasons of Exposure to Teaching, not 3, in 1191-1192. |
| + | |||
| + | ALM - thanks. | ||
His apprenticeship XP seems overspent by 5 points. Suggest dropping either Finesse or Penetration because you can't really use it. | His apprenticeship XP seems overspent by 5 points. Suggest dropping either Finesse or Penetration because you can't really use it. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ALM - I don't know what to say other then Metacreator is wrong. | ||
| + | |||
| + | 0-4 Childhood 45xp | ||
| + | |||
| + | 5-10 Youth 90xp | ||
| + | |||
| + | 11-12 Travel 30xp | ||
| + | |||
| + | 13-28 Apprenticeship + 1 year captivity 240xp | ||
| + | |||
| + | Magic Theory (creating items) 4 - 50xp | ||
| + | Athletics (flight) 4 - +20xp | ||
| + | Faerie Lore 3 - 30xp | ||
| + | Ancient Britain 2 - 15xp | ||
| + | Hunt 2 - 15xp | ||
| + | Charm 2 - 15xp | ||
| + | Ettiquette 2 - 15xp | ||
| + | Intrigue 2 - 15xp | ||
| + | Ledgerdemain 2 - 15xp | ||
| + | Magic Lore 1 - 5xp | ||
| + | Infernal Lore 1 - 5xp | ||
| + | Finesse 1 - 5xp | ||
| + | Penetration 1 - 5xp | ||
| + | Concentration 1 - 5xp | ||
| + | Code of Hermes 1 - 5xp | ||
| + | Artes Liberalis 1 - 5xp | ||
| + | Carouse 1 - 5xp | ||
| + | Sew 1 - 5xp | ||
| + | Leadership 1 - 5xp (Failed Gauntlet) | ||
| + | |||
| + | ALM - This is not the first time I've disagreed with Metacreator. I'd understand a difference of 15xp but not 5xp, as I have childhood going from 0 to 4 while some people could start counting at 1 which would account for a 15xp difference. | ||
| + | |||
| + | AG - OK, I see where you are coming from. You've explained your point of view pretty clearly and I can't point to a flaw in it. Torkel's apprenticeship XP stands. | ||
XP in Great Weapon is too high. Junior grants 9xp per season, not 11. This is probably a mistake on my part. | XP in Great Weapon is too high. Junior grants 9xp per season, not 11. This is probably a mistake on my part. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ALM - no problem. | ||
| + | |||
| + | AG - Thanks | ||
It would really help if you could add future seasons & adventures one at a time instead of lumping them together. | It would really help if you could add future seasons & adventures one at a time instead of lumping them together. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ALM - I'll fix that up. | ||
| + | |||
| + | AG - Thanks, no need to redo anything, just please keep it in mind going forward. | ||
| + | |||
| + | In Spring 1193, Torkel taught Agenes so he gains more exposure XP in Teaching. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ALM - I'll note that. | ||
Latest revision as of 19:07, 6 June 2011
I finally got around to entering Torkel into Metacreator and I found a couple of issues.
First, I had retroactively changed some of Torkel's activities so he only has 2 seasons of Exposure to Teaching, not 3, in 1191-1192.
ALM - thanks.
His apprenticeship XP seems overspent by 5 points. Suggest dropping either Finesse or Penetration because you can't really use it.
ALM - I don't know what to say other then Metacreator is wrong.
0-4 Childhood 45xp
5-10 Youth 90xp
11-12 Travel 30xp
13-28 Apprenticeship + 1 year captivity 240xp
Magic Theory (creating items) 4 - 50xp Athletics (flight) 4 - +20xp Faerie Lore 3 - 30xp Ancient Britain 2 - 15xp Hunt 2 - 15xp Charm 2 - 15xp Ettiquette 2 - 15xp Intrigue 2 - 15xp Ledgerdemain 2 - 15xp Magic Lore 1 - 5xp Infernal Lore 1 - 5xp Finesse 1 - 5xp Penetration 1 - 5xp Concentration 1 - 5xp Code of Hermes 1 - 5xp Artes Liberalis 1 - 5xp Carouse 1 - 5xp Sew 1 - 5xp Leadership 1 - 5xp (Failed Gauntlet)
ALM - This is not the first time I've disagreed with Metacreator. I'd understand a difference of 15xp but not 5xp, as I have childhood going from 0 to 4 while some people could start counting at 1 which would account for a 15xp difference.
AG - OK, I see where you are coming from. You've explained your point of view pretty clearly and I can't point to a flaw in it. Torkel's apprenticeship XP stands.
XP in Great Weapon is too high. Junior grants 9xp per season, not 11. This is probably a mistake on my part.
ALM - no problem.
AG - Thanks
It would really help if you could add future seasons & adventures one at a time instead of lumping them together.
ALM - I'll fix that up.
AG - Thanks, no need to redo anything, just please keep it in mind going forward.
In Spring 1193, Torkel taught Agenes so he gains more exposure XP in Teaching.
ALM - I'll note that.